Valentine’s Day Cookies and Treats Perfect for Your Sweetie!

Cookies are the way to everyone's heart! Spoil your Valentine (or yourself for that matter) with locally made cookies and treats from your favorite shops around central Alabama.

Now is the time to get those orders in before it's too late!

This listing is in random order. Enjoy!

valentine's day cookies

1. Savage’s Bakery

Those conversation candy hearts you know and love have been transformed into adorable conversation heart iced cookies. What better way to say “Be Mine” with these sweet treats! You can order them here as a 6-pack or dozen. They are also available as a dozen on a tray.

Location

2916 18th Street South
Homewood, AL 35209

Visit Website

valentine's day cookies
(Source: Icing on the Cookie Facebook)

2. Icing on the Cookie

Iced cookies from Icing on the Cookie are sure to be a hit for your Valentine! These made-from-scratch sugar cookies are available as an iced bite heart, double heart, lips, sign language, “I Love You” and more!

Location

2907 Central Ave #101
Birmingham, AL 35209

Visit Website

valentine's day cookies
(Source: Dreamcakes Bakery Facebook)

3. Dreamcakes Bakery

Dreamcakes Bakery is helping you share the love with several Valentine’s Day specials. From heart shaped cookie cakes and Valentine’s cookie kits to chocolate dipped strawberries, cupcakes, and iced sugar cookies, the options for your special one are endless.

Location

960 Oxmoor Road
Homewood, AL 35209

Visit Dreamcakes on Facebook

Valentine’s day cookies
(Source: cookiefix.com)

4. Cookie Fix

Get your sweetie a Valentine’s 6-pack of cookies from Cookie Fix! You can purchase fresh baked cookies that are already pre-made and ready to go for $18. Ordering is easy via their website. Click here to place your order.

Location

2854 18th St S.
Homewood, AL 35209

Visit Website

valentine's day cookies
(Source: K&J's Elegant Pastries)

5. K&J’s Elegant Pastries

K&J’s Elegant Pastries is so well-known for their incredible milkshake creations, but they also offer a wide assortment of delicious goodies for your loved one! Choose from an assorted box of dipped strawberries, LOVE cake, cupcakes, and more. Or, stop by and enjoy the LOVE shake topped with a slice of red velvet cheesecake.

Location

236 1st Street South #300
Alabaster, AL 35007

Visit Website

valentine's day cookies
(Source: magicmuffinsonline.com)

6. Magic Muffins

Magic Muffins is widely known for its mouthwatering muffin tops. But, their iced cookies are to die for! They are not only a work of art, but they taste like heaven too. Your sweetheart will love their heart shaped iced cookies with sprinkles.

Location

3150 Overton Road
Birmingham, AL 35223

Visit Website

valentine's day cookies
(Source: Hero Doughnuts Facebook)

7. Hero Doughnuts

Hero Doughnuts announced that it will start selling Valentine’s Day doughnuts on February 11. We can’t help but wonder what delicious flavor creations they will come up with this time! There’s no doubt about it, though, any flavor you choose will be yummy.

Location

3027 Central Ave.
Homewood, AL 35209

Visit Website

valentine's day cookies
(Source: bigskybread.com)

8. Big Sky Bread Company

If you’re looking for a healthier option for your sweetie, Big Sky has whole wheat cookies made with the best ingredients available, whole grain oats, Montana wheat flour, pure cream butter, and grandma’s molasses. Order your Valentine cookie box complete with two packs of chocolate chip cookies. (You can substitute for oatmeal raisin cookies.) They are fresh from the oven and packaged in an adorable box with decorative filler.

Location

1940 Stonegate Drive
Vestavia Hills, AL 35242

Visit Website

9. Church Street Coffee & Books

Church Street Coffee & Books is known for their delicious “Breakup Cookie”, and despite its name, would be a great choice for your Valentine. This chocolate chip cookie is perfectly chewy (and just a little gooey in the middle), with a bit of salt sprinkled on top to make the chocolate taste even sweeter.

Location

81 Church Street
Mountain Brook, AL 35213

Visit Website

valentine's day cookies
(Source: Edgar's Bakery)

10. Edgar’s Bakery

Specially made just in time for Valentine’s Day, you can order an adorable Bee Mine Cake with your choice of butter yellow or chocolate layers with buttercream icing. If smaller treats are more your style, opt for one of their heart cupcakes, petit fours, chocolate covered strawberries, chocolates, or a mini heart cake.

Location

180 Main Street #240
Hoover, AL 35244
(Or location nearest you) See list here.

Visit Website

valentine's day cookies
(Source: insomniacookies.com)

11. Insomnia Cookies

Celebrate the one you love with a delicious and gooey red velvet heart shaped cookie from Insomnia Cookies. The best part about these cookies is that you can have them delivered hot and fresh. You better snag these while supplies last!

Location

1919 11th Avenue South #200
Birmingham, AL 35205

Visit Website

Stay Connected

Stay up to date with all things Magic City Weekend!

Download the app | Like us on Facebook